 |
General
Distillery Profile - keywords (wazzat?)
(<20yo)
Sherry Oranges Caramel Liquorice
Chocolate Oak Apples Vanilla Cake Coffee
(>20yo)
Sherry Dried fruits Caramel
Oranges Pepper Vanilla Rum
Nutmeg Chocolate Smoke |
In
our opinion: coming soon...
What the pros had to say:
coming soon... |
All
the Winners - 90+
(updated November 4, 2007) - Tasting
Notes: Please scroll down |
| Points,
whiskies
96 - Macallan 1954 (80°proof, OB, Campbell,
Hope & King, Rinaldi Italy, late 1960’s)
96 - Macallan 1947 (80 Proof, OB, Rinaldi Import,
+/-1962)
96 - Macallan 1938 (43%, OB, Hand written label
with seal, Imported by Corade France, 75cl)
93 - Macallan 1958 (80°proof, OB, Campbell,
Hope & King, Rinaldi Italy, early 1970’s)
93 - Macallan 25yo 1957/1982 (43%, OB, Anniversary,
Imported by Corade France, 75cl)
93 - Macallan 29yo 1965/1994 (49%, Signatory,
C#1058, 256 Bts., D. 02/'65 Btl. 11/'94)
92 - Macallan 30yo 1976/2006 (45.3%, Adelphi,
C#2749, 206 Bts.)
91 - Macallan 10yo 'Full Proof' (57%, OB, Giovinetti
& Figli, +/-1980, 75cl)
91 - Macallan-Glenlivet 15yo (43%, G&M, Golden
& Black Label, red Letters, 1960's, Italian
imp.)
91 - Macallan 18 yo 1989/2007 ‘sherry’
(43%, OB)
91 - Macallan 1974/2001 (50.5%, Scott's Selection)
91 - Macallan 31yo 1966/1998 (53%, Signatory,
C#4178, 198 Bts.)
91 - Macallan 34yo 1968/2003 (40.2%, Murray McDavid,
Celtic Heartland)
90 - Macallan-Glenlivet 8yo 1989/1997 (61.5%,
Milroy’s)
90 - Macallan 10yo (70° Proof, OB for Halls
& Bramley, +/-1965, 75cl)
90 - Macallan 'Coilltean' 1992/2004 (55%, Samaroli,
new Am. oak, C#8518, 420 Bts.)
90 - Macallan-Glenlivet 15yo (80 Proof, G&M
Licensed Gold Label, mid 1970’s)
90 - Macallan 17yo (43%, OB, +/-1985, Spain)
90 - Macallan 18yo 1970/1988 (43%, OB)
90 - Macallan 18yo 1974/1992 (43%, OB)
90 - Macallan 18yo 1976/1995 (43%, OB)
90 - Macallan 1990/2004 'Exceptional Single Cask'
(59.6%, C#24483, butt)
90 - Macallan 20yo 1974/1994 (55,8%, SMWS, 24.28)
90 - Macallan 25yo 1976/2001 (50%, Silver Seal,
Single Barrel)
90 - Macallan 30yo (43%, OB, +/-2000)
90 - Macallan 'The Buxrud Tasting' (1942-2002) |
| OB
- no vintage |
|
- Macallan
NAS Travellers Edition 'Twenties' (40%, OB,
+/-2001) - no notes - 75
- Macallan
NAS Travellers Edition 'Thirties' (40%, OB,
+/-2001) - no notes - 77
- Macallan
NAS Travellers Edition 'Forties' (40%, OB, +/-2001)
- no notes - 73
- Macallan
NAS Travellers Edition 'Fifties' (40%, OB, +/-2001)
- no notes - 78
- Macallan
NAS '1841' Replica (41.7%, OB) - no notes -
78
- Macallan
'1851 Inspiration' (41.3%, OB, 2006) - 300307
- Macallan
1876 Replica (40.6%, OB) - 060304
- Macallan
'Distiller's Choice’ (40%, OB, circa 2004)
- 300307
- Macallan
‘Whisky Maker's Selection' (42.8%, OB,
circa 2006) - 300307
- Macallan
7 yo (40%, OB, +/-2000, International version)
- no notes - 69
- Macallan
7 yo (40%, OB, +/-2000, Italian version) - no
notes - 79
- Macallan
8 yo (43%, OB, Rinaldi, early 70’s) -
100805
- Macallan
8 yo (43%, OB, Rinaldi, late 70’s) - 100805
- Macallan
8 yo ‘Fine Oak’ (40%, OB, circa
2006) - 300307
- Macallan
10 yo (70 proof, OB label but bottled by G&M,
60’s) - 160905
- Macallan
10 yo (70 proof, OB for Halls & Bramley,
60’s) - 160905
- Macallan
10 yo '100 Proof' (57%, OB, +/-1998) - no notes
- 89
- Macallan
10 yo 'Cask Strength' (58.8%, OB, +/-2000) -
no notes - 87
-
Macallan 10 yo (40%, OB, +/-2000) - no notes
- 75
- Macallan
10 yo (40%, OB, +/-2003) - no notes - 78
- Macallan
10 yo ‘Full Proof’ (57%, OB for
Italy, Giovinetti, 1980’s) - 160206
- Macallan
10 yo 'Fine Oak' (40%, OB, 2004) - 131004
- Macallan
12 yo (43%, OB, +/-1999) - no notes - 84
-
Macallan 12 yo (40%, OB, +/-2001) - no notes
- 82
- Macallan
12 yo Sherry (40%, OB, 2004) - 130904
- 311004
- Macallan
12 yo Fine Oak (40%, OB) - 130904
- 131004
- Macallan
15 yo 'Fine Oak' (43%, OB, 2004) - 131004
- Macallan
17 yo (43%, OB, Spain, 80’s) - 030705
- Macallan
18 yo Fine Oak (43%, OB) - 130904
- 131004
- Macallan
21 yo 'Fine Oak' (43%, OB, 2004) - 131004
- Macallan
25 yo 'Fine Oak' (43%, OB, 2004) - 131004
- Macallan
30 yo (43%, OB, circa 1998) - 130904
- Macallan
30 yo 'Fine Oak' (43%, OB, 2004) - 131004
- Macallan
30 yo 'Fine Oak' (43%, OB, circa 2007) - 190308
|
| OB
- vintage |
|
- Macallan
1938 (43%, OB, Corade France, early 1980’s)
- 181107
- Macallan
1947 (80 proof, OB, Rinaldi Bologna, bottled
circa 1962) - 091204
- Macallan
1948-1961/1981 ‘Royal Marriage’
(43%, OB) - 201106
- Macallan
1950 (43%, OB, Corade France, early 1980’s)
- 181107
- Macallan
1954 (80°proof, OB, Campbell, Hope &
King, Rinaldi Italy, late 1960’s) - 110907
- Macallan
15 yo 1956 (80 proof, OB, Rinaldi) - 160905
- Macallan
25 yo 1957 ‘Anniversary’ (43%, OB)
- 181107
- Macallan
1958 (80°proof, OB, Campbell, Hope &
King, Rinaldi Italy, early 1970’s) - 110907
- Macallan
1963 (43%, OB, square crystal decanter, early
1990’s) - 181107
- Macallan
25 yo 1967/1993 (43%, OB, Anniversary) - 030206
- Macallan
18 yo 1968/1986 (43%, OB) - 190308
- Macallan
18 yo (43%, OB, +/-2000, No vintage, US) - no
notes - 87
- Macallan
18 yo 1970/1988 (43%, OB) - no notes - 90
- Macallan
30 yo 1971/2002 ‘Vintage’ (56.4%,
OB, cask #4280) - 120706
- Macallan
18 yo 1974/1992 (43%, OB) - 201106
- Macallan
18 yo 1976/1994 (43%, OB, Giovinetti) - 171007
- Macallan
18 yo 1976/1995 (43%, OB) - no notes - 90
-
Macallan
18 yo 1978/1996 (43%, OB) - 190204
- Macallan
18 yo 1979/1997 'Gran Reserva' (40%, OB) - 281207
- Macallan
18 yo 1980/1998 (43%, OB) - 311004
- Macallan
1980/2002 'Exceptional Single Cask' (51%, Sherry
Butt, cask #17937, 858 bottles) - no notes -
88
- Macallan
18 yo 1981 'Gran Reserva' (40%, OB, +/-2000)
- no notes - 75
- Macallan
18 yo 1982/2000 (43%, OB) - no notes - 88
- Macallan
18 yo 1983/2001 (43%, OB) - 171007
- Macallan
15 yo 1984 (43%, OB, +/-2000) - no notes - 88
- Macallan
18 yo 1984 (43%, OB) - 120204
- Macallan
18 yo 1986 (43%, OB, old presentation, 2004)
- 210105
- Macallan
18 yo 'sherry' 1986 and earlier (43%, OB, 2004)
- 311004
- 210105
- Macallan
18 yo 1987/2005 ‘sherry’ (43%, OB)
- 171007
- Macallan
18 yo 1989/2007 ‘sherry’(43%, OB)
- 171007
- Macallan
12 yo 'Elegancia' 1990/2002 (40%, OB) - no notes
- 78
- Macallan
1990/2004 'Exceptionnal Single Cask' (59.6%,
butt #24483) - 201205
|
| Adelphi |
|
- Macallan
30 yo 1976/2006 (45.3%, Adelphi, cask #2749,
206 bottles) - 201206
- Macallan
14 yo 1990/2005 (53.9%, Adelphi, cask #10136,
211 bottles) - 201205
|
| Cadenhead
|
|
- Macallan-Glenlivet
17 yo 1962/1979 (80°proof, Cadenhead's for
Samaroli, 360 bottles) - 110907
-
Macallan-Glenlivet
30 yo 1963/1993 (54.7%, Cadenhead) - 190204
- Macallan-Glenlivet
17 yo 1987/2005 (59.1%, Cadenhead Authentic
Coll., sherry butt, 630 bottles) - 201205
|
| Dewar
Rattray |
|
- Macallan
16 yo 1989/2005 (51.3%, Dewar Rattray, cask
#2492, 248 bottles) - 160206
|
| Douglas
Laing |
|
- Macallan
27 yo 1976/2004 (48.5%, DL Platinum, 235 b.,
bourbon) - 060304
- Macallan
29 yo 1977/2006 (50.3%, Douglas Laing Platinum
Series, 185 bottles) - 201206
- Macallan
25 yo 1978/2004 (50%, DL OMC, cask #DL 1214,
258 bottles) - 221104
- Macallan
25 yo 1979/2005 (50%, Douglas Laing OMC, 331
bottles) - 250305
- Macallan
25 yo 1981/2006 (50%, Douglas Laing Old Malt
Cask, 357 bottles) - 201206
- Macallan
18 yo 1989/2007 (50%, Douglas Laing OMC, finished
in rum cask, 306 bottles, ref #3635) - 281207
- Macallan
10 yo 1990/2000 (50%, Douglas Laing OMC, Sherry,
684 bottles) - 261107
|
| Dun
Eideann |
|
- Macallan
8 yo 1990/1998 (61.3%, Dun Eideann, cask #10711,
624 bottles) - 261107
|
| Duncan
Taylor |
|
- Macallan
35 yo 1967 (45.1%, Peerlesss, cask #7678) -
240304
- Macallan
38 yo 1969/2007 (40.4%, Duncan Taylor Rare Auld,
cask #6846, 176 bottles) - 190308
- Macallan
18 yo 1986/2005 (54.9%, Duncan Taylor, cask
#11917) - 110106
- Macallan
1987/2007 (57.7%, Duncan Taylor, cask #9795)
- 070707
- Macallan
19 yo 1988/2008 (53.3%, Duncan Taylor Rare Auld,
cask #8426, 271 bottles) - 190308
|
| Exclusive
Malts |
|
- Macallan
18 yo 1989/2007 (50.6%, Exclusive Malts, finished
in Madiera hogshead, cask #17889, 474 bottles)
- 281207
- Macallan
8 yo 1998 (54.7%, Exclusive Malts, cask #816,
261 bottles, 2007) - 300307
|
| Gordon
& MacPhail |
|
- Macallan
33 yo (43%, Gordon & MacPhail, Pinerolo,
circa 1975) - 280508
- Macallan-Glenlivet
36 yo 1937 (43%, G&M, Co. Import, Pinerolo)
- 091204
- Glen
Gordon 50 yo 1939/1989 (43%, Gordon & MacPhail,
120 bottles) - 280508
- Macallan-Glenlivet
15 yo (43%, G&M licensed bottling, Italy,
60’s) - 160905
- Macallan-Glenlivet
15 yo (80°proof, G&M Licensed, Gold
Label, mid 1970’s) - 110907
- Macallan
1972/2007 (43%, Gordon & MacPhail, Speymalt)
- 281207
- Macallan
1994 (40%, G&M Speymalt) - 180504
- Macallan
1995/2004 (40%, G&M, Speymalt) - 250904
- Macallan
1998/2007 (43%, Gordon & MacPhail, Speymalt)
- 280508
|
| Hart
Bros |
|
- Macallan
12 yo 1990/2003 (46%, Hart Bros, sherry cask)
- 011105
|
| Jean
Boyer |
|
- Macallan
'Macalan' 1991/2004 (57,5%, Jean Boyer Best
Cask, refill hogshead) - 011105
- Macallan
1991/2006 (56,4%, Jean Boyer, Best Cask of Scotland
Collection, Sherry cask) - 201206
- Macallan
1998/2008 (43%, Jean Boyer, Best Casks of Scotland,
Small Barrels) - 280508
|
| Milroy's |
|
- Macallan-Glenlivet
8 yo 1989/1997 (61.5%, Milroy’s) - 110106
|
| Moon
Import |
|
- Macallan
1970/1988 (46%, Moon 'The sea', butt #11306,
780 bottles) - 281207
|
| Murray
McDavid |
|
- Macallan
34 yo 1968/2003 (40.2%, Murray McDavid, Celtic
Heartland)- no notes - - no notes - 91
- Macallan
26yo 1973/2000 (46%, Murray McDavid, Refill
sherry, MM 4755) - 230108
- Macallan
9 yo 1990/1999 (46%, Murray McDavid, Fresh sherry)
- no notes - 89
-
Macallan 10 yo 1990/2001 (46%, Murray McDavid,
fresh sherry) - no notes - 90
- Macallan
17 yo 1990/2007 (52.3%, Murray McDavid, Mission
Gold, Enhanced in Haut-Brion casks, 1,750 bottles)
- 261107
|
| Samaroli |
|
- Macallan
'Coilltean' 1992/2004 (55%, Samaroli, new American
oak, cask #8518, 420 bottles) - 181105
|
| Scott's
Selection |
|
- Macallan
1973/1999 (47%, Scott's Selection) - 230108
- Macallan
1974/2001 (50.5%, Scott's Selection) - 310106
- Macallan
1979/2004 (51.6%, Scott's Selection) - 230108
|
| Signatory
|
|
- Macallan
29 yo 1965/1994 (49%, Signatory, cask #1058,
256 bottles) - 110907
- Macallan
31 yo 1966/1998 (53%, Signatory, cask #4178,
198 bottles) - 030206
- Macallan
27 yo 1971/1999 (54.2%, Signatory, dark sherry
butt #12/096/28, 652 bottles) - 120706
|
| Silver
Seal |
|
- Macallan
25 yo 1976/2001 (50%, Silver Seal, Single Barrel)
- no notes - 90
- Macallan
25 yo 1978/2003 (57.3%, Silver Seal, 236 bottles)
- 060505
- Macallan
13 yo 1990/2003 (46%, Silver Seal, 686 bottles)
- 280404
|
| Single
Malts of Scotland |
|
- Macallan
17 yo 1990/2007 (46%, The Single Malts of Scotland,
small batch) - 261107
|
| SMWS |
|
- Macallan
20 yo 1974/1994 (55,8%, SMWS, 24.28) - no notes
- 90
- Macallan
15 yo 1989/2005 (57.2%, SMWS 24.82) - 181105
|
| Whisky-Doris |
|
- Macallan
14 yo 1990/2005 (46%, Whisky-Doris, sherry cask)
- 011105
|
| Wilson
& Morgan |
|
-
Macallan 1990/2003 (50.5%, Wilson & Morgan,
Extra Strength) - no notes - 81
- Macallan
12 yo 1990/2003 (57.5%, Wilson & Morgan,
Sherry, cask #8748, 637 bottles) - no notes
- 88
- Macallan
1990/2004 Rum Finish (46%, Wilson & Morgan)
- 221104
- Macallan
1991/2004 Extra Strength (50%, Wilson &
Morgan) - 221104
|
| Various
IB |
|
- Macallan
'The Buxrud Tasting' (1942-2002) - no notes
- 90
- Glen
Gordon 15yo 1974/1990 (40%, Antica Casa Marchesi
Spinola, Collection No 1, 75cl) - 230108
- Macallan
1985/2005 (43%, Private Cellar, Forbes &
Ross) - 120406
- Macallan
1985/2006 (43%, Private Cellar Collection) -
230108
- Macallan
1988/2000 'As We Get It' (54.9%, Kirsch Import)
- 310106
- Macallan
12yo ‘Diego’s Experiment’
(40%, Private Finishing, 2007) - 070707
- Macallan
12 yo 1990/2002 as we get it (55.6%, Kirsch
Import) - no notes - 75
- Macallan
14 yo 1990/2004 (53.7%, Engelholm Whiskycircle,
Sweden, bourbon cask #9448) - 060505
- Macallan
16 yo 1990/2006 (46%, Milano Whisky Festival,
cask #1754, 240 bottles) - 261107
- Macallan
14 yo 1991/2005 (46%, The Alchemist, circa 2005)
- 120406
|
|
 |
 |
 |
|